Wiener's laws
Wiener’s laws are a list of aphorisms about automation and human error in aviation, attributed to Earl L. Wiener, a professor at the University of Miami and a NASA scientist. The aphorisms are often quoted in relation to automation in general, not related to aviation specifically, and have crossed into literature on general computing and cyber-security.
Asaf Degani’s list
The laws first appeared in the “Things with Wings” online blog of the Aviation Week magazine, in July 2013, shortly after Wiener died. William Langewiesche published a different list in Vanity Fair about a year later, not providing a source. Peter Day also published a list in an article for BBC News, crediting Vanity Fair, but providing a list that is different from the one actually published by Vanity Fair. Daniel Geer published an article for IEEE Security & Privacy in 2015 repeating some of the laws and applying them to cybersecurity automation, mostly crediting Langewiesche.
The table below shows the 15 laws as numbered and worded by Aviation Week, and which of them appear in other versions. The Aviation Week version numbering starts at 17, under the line “(Note: Nos. 1-16 intentionally left blank)”, adding to the humorous nature of the “laws”.
| No. | Law (Aviation Week, 2013) | Vanity Fair (2014) | BBC (2014) | In Wiener’s own publications |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | Every device creates its own opportunity for human error. | yes | yes | loose echo (1993) |
| 18 | Exotic devices create exotic problems. | yes | yes | loose echo (1993) |
| 19 | Digital devices tune out small errors while creating opportunities for large errors. | yes | yes | yes, in other words (1985) |
| 20 | Complacency? Don’t worry about it. | — | yes | not found |
| 21 | In aviation, there is no problem so great or so complex that it cannot be blamed on the pilot. | — | yes | not found |
| 22 | There is no simple solution out there waiting to be discovered, so don’t waste your time searching for it. | — | yes | not found |
| 23 | Invention is the mother of necessity. | yes | yes | not found |
| 24 | If at first you don’t succeed… try a new system or a different approach. | — | yes | not found |
| 25 | Some problems have no solution. If you encounter one of these, you can always convene a committee to revise some checklist. | first sentence only | yes | not found |
| 26 | In God we trust. Everything else must be brought into your scan. | — | yes | not found |
| 27 | It takes an airplane to bring out the worst in a pilot. | yes | yes | not found |
| 28 | Any pilot who can be replaced by a computer should be. | — | yes | not found |
| 29 | Whenever you solve a problem you usually create one. You can only hope that the one you created is less critical than the one you eliminated. | yes | yes | not found |
| 30 | You can never be too rich or too thin (Duchess of Windsor) or too careful what you put into a digital flight guidance system (Wiener). | reworded | — | not found |
| 31 | Today’s nifty, voluntary system is tomorrow’s F.A.R. | — | — | not found |
The acronym F.A.R in law 31 refers to the US Federal Aviation Regulations.
The list as a whole has no known source document, and only a few of the rules can actually be traced to Wiener’s writing. Aviation Week credits the list to Asaf Degani, a close collaborator of Wiener. Langewiesche claims that Wiener wrote the list in the 1980s without providing a reference. Geer presents the workload statement as Langewiesche’s rewording of Wiener’s laws.
“Not found” in the last column means that we could not find the wording in the five Wiener publications we hold (from 1980, 1985, 1989, 1993 and a 1988 workshop talk published in 1989).
The workload “law”
Langewiesche introduced one more statement in the spirit of Wiener’s laws, explaining that automation reduces workload when it is already low and increases it when it is already high. This law does not appear in the Aviation Week list, and Langewiesche paraphrases it without a clear source, but Wiener did write about a similar idea. In a 1989 NASA report, Wiener wrote that his early work, starting with the 1980 paper with Curry, had found that workload was not universally reduced by automation: “In fact it appeared that a paradox existed: workload seemed to be reduced when it was not heavy or critical, and may be increased by automation when it was already heavy or critical.”
The origins of Wiener’s Laws
The idea behind law 19 goes back to a 1980 paper by Wiener and Renwick Curry, Flight-deck automation: promises and problems, which lists “relief from small errors” among the advantages of automation, and “systems are fault intolerant” and “may lead to larger errors” among the disadvantages. In a 1985 essay Beyond the Sterile Cockpit, Wiener wrote that “as a generalization, it appears that automation tunes out small errors and creates opportunities for large ones.” Note that this was about “automation”, not “digital devices”.
Wiener’s 1993 NASA report on intervention strategies for human error contains ideas similar to several laws. Similar to law 17, the report suggests that “the high technology aircraft offer new opportunities for human error”. Similar to law 18 (but referring to software, and not devices), Wiener writes that “computer-based systems, particularly as their programs become more exotic, can themselves generate never-before errors.”
None of the remaining laws appears in the Wiener publications we were able to trace. Wiener wrote about complacency often (law 20 seems to be a joke at the expense of that topic), and the remaining laws read more like the maxims from lectures.
Law 23, “Invention is the mother of necessity” inverts the proverb necessity is the mother of invention, usually traced back to Plato’s Republic and to the moral of Aesop’s fable of the crow and the pitcher. Jared Diamond made the same inversion the argument of the chapter “Necessity’s Mother” in his 1997 book Guns, Germs, and Steel (note that Diamond does not attribute the phrase to anyone). After listing major inventions that were developed first and found a use later, from the airplane to the transistor, he concludes: “Thus, invention is often the mother of necessity, rather than vice versa.” Two years later he used it as the title of his essay on the best invention of the millennium for The New York Times Magazine, explaining: “Actually, invention is the mother of necessity, by creating needs that we never felt before.” Diamond’s book is 16 years older than the earliest dated copy of Wiener’s list. Because the list itself cannot be dated, it is not clear whether Wiener borrowed the line, whether Diamond did, or whether they independently reached the same play on words from a well-known proverb.